Turkey Offers U.S. Armenian Diaspora $20M to Catalogue Dashnak Archives in Boston

Dashnak archives in Boston

The Armenian diaspora in the U.S. refuses to open the Dashnak archives in Boston to the public claiming that it lacks the funds to catalogue the documents lodged there.

That is an interesting assertion in light of the millions of dollars paid by the Armenian diaspora to lobby Congress, build memorials and even a museum. It's odd that they can build a museum, but continue to claim they cannot catalogue their historical archives. Which raises an interesting question--what are they putting in the museum if their archives are such a mess?

So Turkey has generously proposed a win-win solution: Turkey is offering the U.S. Armenian diaspora $20 million to pay the costs of cataloguing the Dashnak archives located in Boston.

The ball in now in the U.S. diaspora's court. Will they accept? refuse? or ignore the offer altogher?

Well, here's a response... greedy greedy response... does he really think Turkey would just hand over the money to them? Hah!

Armenians Should Take $20 Million Offered by Turkey as Partial Payment By Harut Sassounian
The California Courier

The largest Turkish daily newspaper, Hurriyet, carried the following sensational headline in its May 20, 2008 edition: "Turkey offers $20 million aid to open Armenian archives."

Yusuf Halacoglu, chairman of Turkey's state-funded Turkish Historical Society, told Hurriyet that he had offered Armenians $20 million to open the ARF archives in Boston which he says include "very important documents" regarding the Armenian Genocide.

Halacoglu said that he made this financial offer after Armenians allegedly told him that they do not have the necessary funds to organize these archives. He claimed that "Armenians do not want to have the archives opened because such efforts will start a real debate over the genocide claims."

In recent years, Halacoglu has made many bizarre statements on the Armenian Genocide, bringing nothing but ridicule upon himself, his fellow genocide denialists, and the Turkish Historical Society. This latest offer is yet another wacky statement by this charlatan, masquerading as a historian. It shows his own, and his government's desperation in trying to counter what Hurriyet describes as the Armenian Diaspora's increasing worldwide activities in recent years for the acknowledgment of the Armenian Genocide.

There are several falsehoods in Halacoglu's statement. First, he does not say which Armenians, if any, had told him that they lack the necessary funds to catalogue the ARF archives in Boston. It is a pretty sure bet that he has never contacted a single ARF official regarding the status of these archives. If he had, he would have learned that these archives are already open to any serious scholar. I am also quite certain that no ARF official has ever told Halacoglu that the archives are not catalogued due to funding issues, because many of the documents have already been published in several volumes. Since Halacoglu knows neither Armenian nor any other language besides Turkish, he would be unable to read a single document located in these archives.

Halacoglu claims that he had conveyed his offer of $20 million to "two Armenian historians, Ara Sarafian and Hilmar Kaiser," and had not received an answer. Betraying the depth of his ignorance, Halacoglu cannot even tell that Hilmar Kaiser is a German and not an Armenian!

Tatul Sonentz-Papazian, who managed the ARF archives in Boston until 2000, was quoted by the Armenian Reporter as saying that, contrary to Halacoglu's claims, the cataloguing of the ARF documents through 1925 were completed in1995. Mr. Sonentz-Papazian told the Armenian Reporter that Hilmar Kaiser, whom he had seen as recently as a month ago, did not convey such an offer from Halacoglu. Ara Sarafian also contradicted Halacoglu's claims by telling the Reporter that he had not been asked to convey such an offer to the ARF. "This is obviously a publicity stunt," Sarafian was quoted as saying. "Halacoglu thrives on such publicity."

Furthermore, there is no evidence that the ARF archives will lend any credence to the cause of genocide denialists. Gerard Libaridian, who was incharge of the ARF archives in Boston from 1982 to 1988, posted the following explanation on the armworkshop website on March 26, 2007: "I doubt that they [ARF archives] will shed much light on the genocidal process itself, since the leaders of that party, both national and local, were among the first victims of that process=80¦. These archives, of course, cannot be lumped in the same basket as state archives, since the Dashnaktsutiune [ARF] is a political organization and not a state."

Halacoglu would do well to be more concerned about the accessibility and integrity of Ottoman/Turkish archives rather than those of the ARF. In the May 25, 2008 issue of the Turkish newspaper, Taraf, researcher Ayse Hur, in a detailed and lengthy report, courageously exposed the destruction and manipulation of the Ottoman archives. The Taraf article is appropriately titled, "Leave the Tashnak archives alone and look at the Ottoman archives." Over the past nine decades, the Ottoman archives have been cleansed from all incriminating documents and made available mostly to denialist "scholars" hired by the Turkish government.

My advice to the officials in charge of the ARF archives is to take the $20 million being offered by the Turkish government and declare that sum to be a partial compensation for the billions of dollars of damages suffered by Armenians during the Genocide. Whenever Armenians have an opportunity to recover even a small portion of their immense losses during the genocide, be it money, personal property or other assets, they should grab it without hesitation!

even if this article is read by an objective person who has no previous information about this issue, it smells like trying to cover up the contents of the archives and throwing the ball right back to the Turks. So if these archives are already open, why do they go off in length about how "these archives will not shed any light upon the issue"? What are they trying to hide? Why prevent Ottoman scholars from looking at them if there's nothing useful in them?

Also the last paragraph is way too greedy and sided to make them look like "angels" to ANYBODY reading the article. "They should grab it without hesitation!" does not give any "victimy" feel to the writer. It actually portrays the idea of a thief in my mind. I mean, they would be well advised to pay attention to the tone of their articles, as it brings out their ulterior motives as well as the hatred and enmity beneath.


Post a Comment

The form below could be used for:
# Anonymous Dob In Line,
# your comments & feedback,
# pasting your several pageful of articles to be published here at this site.

# also leave your name & email address, if you want to be contacted
# and write "Confidential" at the top and bottom of your message if you do not want your comment or feedback to to be published here

Anonymous Posting Details:
(We publish Your IP address & tracking info if anonymous)
After entering your text in the comment box,
Please select profile as "Anonymous" within the "Comment As" DropDown Menu, or just select Name/URL & enter your name or your web address,

Then publish it by clicking on the "POST COMMENT" button, below.